Monday, February 11, 2008

Case of the Depressed Patient Case Study Analysis



Recap and analyze the relevant facts - When seriously ill patients ask to discontinue life-sustaining treatment, depression may be impairing their ability to make decisions. (Depressed Patient) In this case, R.L is suffering from diabetes, heart disease and kidney problems, and has been diagnosed with depression. His doctor made this observation when R.L started to loose interest in the things he used to enjoy. R.L has talked about killing himself with a handgun, and agrees to start medication for his depression. While on medication, R.L suffers a heart attack. The damage was so severe, dialysis is necessary to keep him alive. Dialysis can be very difficult and stressful, R.L demands that dialysis be stopped and that he be allowed to die. All his doctor could think was had depression rendered him incapable of making a legitimate life-and-death decision? (Depressed Patient)

It is a patients right to refuse medical treatment, but their decision should be made by a process called informed consent. It is the doctor’s duty to disclose information about the medical conditions, treatment option, possible complications, and expected outcomes with or without treatment. (Depressed Patient) With R.L’s depression, his doctor feels he is not able to make an independent decision about his own life.

The dilemma here is- is R.L’s doctor denying him the right to refuse treatment. It is a doctor’s responsibility to consider whether depression has altered a patients mind and their decision making. R.L agreed to continue on the medication to see if his decision would change, it did not. R.L was removed from dialysis and died six days later. There is research showing that depressed patients don’t necessarily choose to accelerate death in the first place and that they often make the same decisions after they recover from the depression. Should R.L have been denied his human right to refuse medical treatment?
By Heather Lynch

Determining the Root Problem –
The problem in this case is not that R.L has the right to stop treatment or not. The root problem in R.L’s case is determining if he has the ability to give informed consent. Informed consent means that “the patient must be acting voluntarily and must have the capacity to make the decision” (Depressed Patient). In cases where depression is suspected, it can be very hard for physicians to determine if the patient is making a logical, informed choice.
By Rob Steenwyk

Identifying the Problem Components –
There are many components to determining if R.L was able to meet the requirements for informed consent. The first step to determining informed consent is finding if the patient has any sort of mental illness. If they don’t, than the patient should be able to refuse treatment without any further questioning. If they do, as in the case of R.L with depression, medication should be considered that can mitigate the symptoms of their illness. Once the medicine has been administered for the proper amount of time, the patient should again be asked what their decision is. If it is still consistent, the patient should be allowed to refuse treatment. If medication was unable to mitigate the problems of the mental illness, the family should then be brought in to make a decision.
By Rob Steenwyk


Generating Alternatives -
If depression is shown to alter ones thinking and decision making, then help from the patient’s family should come into play. It is a patients right to refuse medication, a doctor should not deny any patient their own right. The family knows the patient more than any doctor and if they will not allow the patient to make their own decision then maybe the family should have a say. The patient, along with his/her family should be able to make a solid decision on such an issue. Before going on any life sustaining treatment the patient should have to sign a form for allowing the family to help make such a decision. This way they can make the decision together and overrule the doctor’s opinion.
Another alternative is to do more research on the depressed patient. Once some solid research has been found on depressed patients it can be applied to the situation. Laws can be formed to protect the patient even further. Either the patient will be able to make this decision by themselves no matter what the problem; of they can be denied by their doctor and have to wait until after the depression has subsided. As for now, it sounds like this situation is based only on ethics and is up in the air.
There appears to be severe, moderate, and mild forms of depression. Depending on how severe one is, could have a say on the situation:
• Severe depression- is present when a person has nearly all of the symptoms of depression, and the depression almost always keep them from doing their regular day to day activities.
• Moderate depression- is present when a person has many symptoms of depression that often keep them from doing things they need to do.
• Mild depression- is present when a person has some of the symptoms of depression and it takes extra effort to do the things they need to do.

One way they could judge the dilemma is depending on how severe the depression is, maybe only the sever patients should need more help from their doctor and or from family.
By Heather Lynch

Generating Alternatives - Now we are looking at the alternatives. In most cases the patient is too far gone and the doctors then take over, making decisions for them. However, in this case that was not the situation. This patient remained fully aware of their surroundings up to the end. Therefore, the only alternative was to allow the patient to decide their own fate, based on their feelings, lifestyle choices, doctors, treatments and situation.

The depressions suffered by this patient could be listed as Moderate depression brought on by their lifestyle changing situation. This being the case, they would not be listed as needing someone other than themselves listed as their primary decision maker. They, in fact, were of sound enough mind and body to make the primary decisions for themselves. Putting a fine point on the situation, his doctor made the observation that R.L started to lose interest in the things he use to enjoy and was heard talking about killing himself. After several personal hits to his way of life and feelings, these feelings R.L. was experiencing were normal. The doctors were now faced with a choice; go against the feelings and wishes of their patient, listing him as incapable of taking care of himself, or – allow him the right to die with dignity.
By Jon Haworth

Choosing an alternative - The doctors came to the only decision that served their patient’s best interest. In R.L.’s case, the doctor consulted with a psychiatrist and continued the medication for depression as well as continuing the dialysis. After five weeks, he showed no improvement. His wife refused to allow a feeding tube. R.L had a strong desire to die his own way. His wife saw his desires and needs satisfied. In the end, the doctors allowed the family’s and R.L.’s right to decide and halted all treatment. Six days later he died. He died as he wished to, just as he lived, in charge of his own mind, body and soul.
By Jon Haworth